Prayer
plants do their praying at night. When you turn the light on, she just thinks it's time to get up and go to work, so she unfolds her hands.
I have far better success rooting my cuttings in moist vermiculite. It's much quicker and there is far less stress when it is time to
plant the cutting.
Are ther any leaf nodes submerged in the water? That is necessary because that is where your new roots will develop. Give the cutting another week or so, then you might consider
appropriatinganother cutting and trying again, using moist vermiculite.
Good luck!